A breath test for COVID
For anyone who doesn’t enjoy being swabbed, news of a new
COVID breath test may be welcome. Claimed as the first “ultra-rapid COVID-19
detection technology” a Finnish medical company has just received CE certification
for their device, which means it can now be sold across Europe.
The device, called a BreathPass™
is portable and handheld. It analyses exhaled breath to detect COVID-19
infection. Simply blowing into the device once, like a breathalyser, can
provide a positive or negative reading within 45 seconds.
If proven to be effective (sensitivity and specificity
matter greatly) the devices may provide a welcome alternative to swabbing in
asymptomatic screening. The speed at which the device may be able to work means
it may have great benefit for workplaces, airports or sports events, where mass
screening at speed may be very helpful.
How does the COVID breath test work?
The device contains a set nanosensors that record Volatile
Organic Compounds (VOC) and other substances connected to biomarkers in exhaled
breath gas. The device then communicates the results to an Artificial
Intelligence cloud-based algorithm, which calculates how the VOC profile
matches known COVID-19 features.
Similar approaches are used in the treatment of chronic
obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) and are also being developed to try and
detect many illnesses at an early stage.
The device is described as a fast, easy and affordable
testing method for detecting COVID-19 infection, that can be done anywhere with
a reliable connection to the internet.
What evidence is there that it works?
Sadly, there is very little easily accessible evidence that
the device has been through large scale trials, as yet. The data that has been
published so far refers to very small trial sizes, some involving just ten people.
The trials were not randomised or ‘blind’, which makes it very difficult to be
certain that the device is accurate and reliable.
The data
sheets provided by the manufacturer have very few references to trials or
evaluations, other than previous evaluations of other devices tracking VOCs.
Again, the trials were incredibly limited in scope and size, so it’s difficult
to draw solid conclusions about the effectiveness of the approach.
Can a diagnosis really be made from a breath?
Although the evidence behind the Finnish COVID breath test
is currently unclear, there is mounting evidence that VOC’s may offer a
cost-effective and rapid route to diagnosis for many conditions. Companies all over the world are attempting similar approaches.
Owlstone Medical,
another manufacturer of similar devices, has published many more research
papers, several of which are larger and independent. Owlstone Medical first
hit the headlines in 2017 and has extended their research and product base
considerably since the business was founded.
The NHS
Health Research Agency had considered trials with one device, although it
is now being evaluated in South Carolina, USA, in a trial running until September this year. The results are likely to be published soon after the trial is
completed.
When will the devices be available?
Although the devices need more trials to prove they are safe
and effective, it’s likely that in coming years we may well see similar devices
being used widely in healthcare settings.
Safety may not seem a big deal, because blowing in a tube
isn’t very risky. However, the risk of being given an incorrect result, which
could result in accidental infection of others (from a ‘false negative’) or
unnecessary medical treatment (following a ‘false positive’) has to be
excluded.
If they are proven to work well, they may be very well
suited to health screening, so we expect to see them used widely in corporate
health assessment programmes.
Whilst a COVID breath test may offer hope of a rapid
alternative to swabbing, even the best machines do not match the performance
standards of some of nature’s best sniff testers – dogs.
In a study we first
covered in May 2021, dogs were shown to be highly effective at detecting
COVID-19. They are excellent at finding drugs, explosives, bodies and even
viruses. Their diagnostic skills are not to be sniffed at, but they may not be
quite as well suited to being used in corporate health assessments.
About Occupational Health Assessment Ltd
Occupational Health Assessment Ltd provides
rapid access to expert occupational health support for
businesses across the United Kingdom. Appointments are available within
two days.
With a unique occupational health assessment
service, fitness certifications and access to clinics
in Belfast, Birmingham, Bradford, Brighton, Bristol, Cardiff, Coventry, Derby, Edinburgh, Glasgow, Hull, Leeds, Leicester, Liverpool, London, Manchester, Newcastle, Northampton, Nottingham, Plymouth, Portsmouth, Reading, Sheffield, Southampton, Stoke, Surrey and more,
the business provides high quality, expert medical advice.
Please contact
us for further information or assistance.